Thursday, 20 August 2026

In terms of, Redacted, and Government Investment


In terms of

The phrase has been part of English language for hundreds of years, says Collins, and it certainly has its legitimate use. One can say with perfect grammatical propriety 'In terms of imperial units, he was above six feet'. The terms one is speaking of are literally terms.  But its freer use, a not-so-obviously-legitimate use extended to various aspects of the subject-matter, has been widespread only since the 1970s, and furthermore -- to my ears -- has grown markedly in the past twenty years. 

To give it its due, it's an extremely flexible way of combining ideas:  

1. 'He was controversial in terms of his choice of goalkeeper', instead of 'His choice of goalkeeper was controversial'. 

2. 'In terms of his policies, he was very successful', for 'His policies were very successful'. 

3. 'What the effect on the homeless, in terms of not knowing this?', for 'How does not knowing this affect the homeless?'

4. 'What is happening of late in terms of violence and burglary?' for 'What violence and burglary have happened of late?'. 

5. 'He's got to be better, in terms of getting back on defense', for 'He's got to be better at getting back on defense'.  

6. 'In terms of money, the car cost five dollars', for 'The car cost five dollars'.  

7. 'In terms of quality, this product is excellent', for 'The quality of this product is excellent'.

8. 'In terms of price, this car is superb' for 'The price of this car is superb'.

9. 'The city grew a lot in terms of population', for 'The city's population grew a lot'.  

10. 'In terms of food it was great but in terms of weather it was terrible' for 'The food was great but the weather was terrible'. 

But it has a flattening as well as homogenizing effect. It's lazy. Often it is substituted for a preposition or relative clause, as in 7, 8 or 9 (but sometimes it is plainly vacuous, as in 6 or 10). I think -- as a rough guess -- what joins the more substantive cases together is that one seizes upon a single adjective, verb or noun (or phrase of same), but rather than fine-tuning it, with for example a preposition, as in 7 (call it a 'qualifier'), one says 'in terms of', then the qualifier, and then applies the main verb to the unqualified subject. The fine-tuning often calls for some grammatical panache, an effort which one is spared by using 'in terms of'. 

(Earlier, quick treatment of 'in terms of', at the end). 

Redacted -- unredacted

Is it just me? These are old terms but I don't recall their being commonly used until The Epstein Files. Now, whenever I run across them, I think of Epstein. 

We're investing record amounts in X! 


A pet peeve concerning politicians -- I have a zooful of such pets -- which is an easy dodge but no one calls them out on it. An reporter or interviewer states a problem, say an increase in waiting times for cancer-screening. The politician reacts by saying: 'That's why we're investing record amounts in cancer-screening!'  You see the problem? Say the NHS budget is set every three years. Say the UK infation rate was an average of 2.5% in each of the three years, so roughly 7.7% over the three years. When the politician spoke of 'amounts', it is not, you can bet your sweet bipee, figures adjusted for inflation. That way the politician can say he was speaking truth, even if, in fact, the government's cancer-screen spending, correcting for inflation, has gone down in comparison with its level three years ago. 

Sunday, 25 January 2026

Iconicity, Scrambled Jets, Compose/Comprise (reprise)

Iconic. 

I don't know very much of the history of this phenomenon, but I imagine it really got up and running in the 1970s, for whatever reason. Google says 'Something is iconic if it has achieved a level of fame where it stands for something larger than itself.' So Marilyn Monroe is iconic. To be called 'iconic' is the dream of, say, Madonna. Which brings me to the point: Icons, in an older sense of the word, are usually Byzantine portaits of saints. Things of reverence, to worship; there is something holy about them. Is the idea behind the modern use of the word is to hint that the referent is a person likewise to be held up as a higher than ordinary people, that their symbolic significance in the world of fame is of a higher plane? Yes of course. To me, Google seems to have it spot on -- but the affinity with the older sense of the word is not accidental. What is going on is not that people want fame for being famous. No, at least not explicitly; that would be too transparent. There is something religious in this desire. And just because fame is the currency, people are going to covet that status whatever the basis, and will do what they can to encourage others to bestow it upon them. Indeed a peculiar trait of fan-culture is that the fans are often fixated on bestowing it. They make lists of 'icons' and debate about them. Here are three such lists, got from the Internet.

This first list of mostly Hollywood stars seems to fit my sense of the words, which connotes that the figure has permament staying power: 

  1. Marlene Dietrich. 
  2. Katherine Hepburn.
  3. Bette Davis. 
  4. Joan Crawford. 
  5. Greta Garbo.
  6. Elizabeth Taylor. 
  7. Humphrey Bogart. 
  8. Cary Grant. 
  9. Spencer Tracy. 
  10. John Wayne. 
No doubt taking the term as closer to just 'famous': 
  1. Johnny Depp. 
  2. Leonardo DiCaprio. 
  3. Morgan Freeman. 
  4. Will Smith. 
  5. Heath Ledger. 
  6. Christopher Nolan. (Who?) 
  7. Helena Bonham Carter.
  8. Sacha Baron Cohen (!). 
And (Pop music stars): 
  1. Elvis Presley. 
  2. Madonna.
  3. John Lennon. 
  4. Michael Jackson.
  5. Beyonce. 
  6. Taylor Swift. 
  7. Tina Turner. 
  8. Dolly Parton. 
I can't help but think this phenomonon is a symptom of people's need to deify. It is not accidental that it arose with the decline of religon. Well, that, in combination with the rise of mass media. There were no icons (in the newer sense) until the first films and music recordings (Greta Garbo, Caruso).  

Scrambled Jets.

Another case of my shaking my fist at the radio or TeeVee. Whenever military jets are suddenly flown for defensive purposes, the newcasters say that the jets have been 'scrambled'. Always, as if they can't let the chance slip for using that word. One has the image of eggs being scrambled in a bowl, suggesting, like the paths in bits of yolk, the image of sudden incoherence in the paths of the individual jets -- or something -- which is a bit alarming. Or maybe the comparison is between a quick making of an omelette for dinner and the quick take-offs of the jets. But not anything more, that I can see. So what is the point of this insistence of this rather unusual form of words? People naturally think that it does have a precise meaning, but are uncertain exactly what meaning it is. I think that it is case of our newscasters adopting a bit of faux technical seriousness, positively revelling in the chance to speak as the experts do, as in the case of 'triage'. Even if it does have a technical, militaristic meaning, I doubt many people know what it is. A comment on Political Wire reads: "Scramble the B-52 Stratofortress to the scene!"

Another one is to 'Shelter in place'. When some terrorist incident or danger such as an outbreak of rabid dogs or a dangerous virus is happening, one is instructed to do this. What does it mean? It means: 'Stay inside!' But I worry that people may be puzzled over what else they're supposed be doing. 'Am I doing it right? Will a leuitenant chastise me for not sheltering in place properly?' 
 

Comprise and Compose (reprise). 

Long ago I observed that these two words are not interchangeable. Still, 'is comprised of' is often wrongly used for 'is composed of'. Roughly: 'Comprise' is a counterposed version of 'compose'. The correct way of speaking, for example, is that six chapters compose the book, but that the book comprises six chapters; that a group comprises its members, whereas the members compose a group. We can also say that the group (say the Beatles) is composed of its members (John, Paul, George and Ringo), but not that the group is comprised of its members. 

I want to note now the obvious point that this sort of pattern is widespread -- where words A and B are similar phonetically and indeed lexically and therefore, erronously, thought the same. A person thinks comprises is just fancy for composes, and the misuse spreads (or maybe it is widespread just because of the similarity, not so much due to copying others). Excusable because the two are so similar. It is like instants and incidences, flaunted and flouted, egregious and outrageous, fortunate and fortuitous, the one is easily mistaken for the other. 

Tuesday, 28 October 2025

Satiated, 24/7, Gin and Ginger, Escalate and Triage

Gin and Ginger

I heard Laura Kunnsberg saying that Labour wants to "ginger up" their voters. I've always thought that the expression is to "gin up" the voters. You can see the meaning of "ginning up": They want to get their voters feeling good (as if getting them drunk). The meaning is lost with "gingering up" the voters.  Also the expression to 'G-up your ginger' is heard, i.e., to bolster's your confidence. Maybe Laura was half-referencing that. 

Satisfied and Satiated 

This one has been around for some time, even if it remains rare. Amanda Marcotte, a blogger speaking about Israel and Iran to the New Republic: "I think that a lot of the people that pressured him into this bombing are not going to be satiated by that. I don’t think Benjamin Netanyahu is going to be satiated."

Satiated as fancy for 'satisfied?'  It's not. Perhaps satiated implies satisfied, but not the reverse; 'satiated' generally applies only to matters of eating -- perhaps not even, as 'satisfied' vaguely suggests agreeableness, whereas 'satiatied' vaguely suggests over-indulgence, disagreeableness. Does Marcotte intend that Netanyahu literally has a positive appetite to bomb Iran, that it affords him pleasure? Maybe he does have such an appetite, but Marcotte is skating on thin ice journalistically by implying it.   

Building with Opening Hours

I've heard this twice in the past year.  A fairly ingrained way of speaking is: 'The corner shop is open 24/7', meaning that the shop is open twenty-four hours per day, seven days per week. The slight mis-perception leads a speaker to say: 'The corner shop is open 24 by 7'. A mild confusion with speaking of a standard lumber size as 'two by four' (in the UK: 'four by two'). I say it's a mild confusion because you can then ask, of the lumber, 'And how long is it?'; whereas there is no analogous question about the shop. 

'Escalate', 'Triage'

This might be only a remark about me (hypersensitive me). I'm not at all sure of this. As far as I know, and strictly speaking, these words are not used incorrectly, by and large. But I feel their use is strange, at least by people interviewed on the radio, the internet or the teevee. First, the average listener is probably vague on the meaning of the terms. Second, I'm not confident that the interviewee really knows these words, or could 'define' them (especially in the case of 'triage'), that is, explain what is meant by the words. Third, the words -- again especially 'triage' -- are used in highly specific contexts (a overworked medic's decisions about who to treat etc., going on urgency and other factors), to sound important, a bit of insider's technical talk to show competence. But to 'escalate' almost always sounds bad as employed by the interviewee, not only implicitly importing ideas of warfare but that the act referred to is unjustifed. But the word carries no such meaning -- escalation is sometimes right and justifed. Together, these points suggest that these words should not be used (in the context of the news etc.); their use is a recipe for miscommunication.   

Tuesday, 15 April 2025

How do you feel? 


This is perhaps an observation that could have been made sixty years ago, but it's one of those things that, the longer it goes on, the more stark the phenomenon. This is the practice -- amongst British journalists, including especially sports journalists -- of asking a person -- the winner of a cup, a witness of some dramatic geopolitical event, or one who has just seen their house swept away in a flood -- 'How do you feel?'  Not what do you think, what is your reaction, but how do you feel? Not quite as if one might respond with 'Oh, an odd tingling between the shoulder blades', but almost. I am quite certain that the British journalist is aware at least subliminally of the British reputation for having a stiff upper lip, of being made uncomfortable at any feelings being on display, and is anxious to show that that reputation is quite unwarranted. I think that it is the Americans as well as the British public who are chiefly in the journalist's thoughts, not the Europeans. Americans have this reputation here for being free with their feelings, of letting it all hang out (think of Little Richard, Janis Joplin, etc.), and the British, however wrongly, do feel inferior on that subject. This is connected with that peculiar way, when an interviewee begins to be overcome with emotion; the jackpot being when they actually break down in tears, and the interviewer goes silent, the camera zooms in. You know it's a case of high-fives all round amongst the production team.  

Trump 

A stratagem that our fearsome leader often employs, and is not called out as often as one would like, is for example this: 

He told reporters on Air Force One on Sunday evening, referring to the attack that killed 34 and injured at least 117 people: "I think it was terrible and I was told they made a mistake, but I think it's a horrible thing. I think the whole war is a horrible thing”. 

It was of course that latest Russian bombing of a Ukranian city, replete with obliterated children and disemboweled old ladies, which Trump avers was just a mistake, an honest mistake, could have happened to anyone. Then he adds 'I think the whole war is a horrible thing'. Not a crime, or even an injustice. Just a horrible thing, so many people died, a shame that it happened. Why? He certainly does not want to assign blame to his overlord, Vladmir Putin. Indeed he wants to see Putin successful; but he knows that this is not the view of anyone outside of Russia (well Belarus, Slovakia, North Korea). Also he has designs on Ukranean minerals however flighty, as well as being loathe to cross Putin in general (perhaps for reasons connected with Golden Showers). So he feints: He stresses how 'horrible' the bombing was (his voice rising) gambling that that momentary show of feeling with the mainstream will be enough, that the conversation will move on to other topics. 

Thursday, 19 September 2024

Like is Out, Yeah is In.

 'Like' on the way out. 'Like: __' was often used, for example, as a device of indirect quotation, where the quoted material is first-person, and one acts out the speech expressing what one thought or felt on the occasion. "Like: 'What is this guy doing?'"; "Like: 'I was all woo-woo", you know?'. 

At around the same time, 'Yeah!' has come in, or rather has come to play a new role. In this usage, it is not a response to the interlocutor's statement or question, but occurs within one's overall speech, mostly but not entirely as a space-filler, between sentences. It is used among other things to announce a change of topic, or just to sustain a positive vibe while keeping the floor -- to decide either on the next topic, or to keep on with the present one. Often it signals that the next utterance will sum up the previous ones. 

While I'm at it, the use of the term 'obviously' -- in this role it has been around a while -- is interesting (alternative: 'Clearly ...'). I hear it as: 'What I'm about to say perhaps goes without saying, but nevertheless I say it just to be absolutely sure there is no misunderstanding, and it's worth saying for the sake of what I'm going to say after, even if in saying it I might accused of talking down to you.'  


Invertebrate and Inveterate, Incredible and Incredulous, Prelude and Predicate

My diagnosis of (one aspect of) changes in language runs as follows. A relatively common word is in use (say 'outrageous', 'uninterested', or 'deny') and another relatively rare word that expresses a different, typically more complicated meaning, which often sounds similar to the first one (say 'egregious',  'disinterested', or 'refute'). Perhaps imagining a certain show of erudition, people begin to use the latter word for the former, not being aware that the latter does not mean the same as the former. But then, if the virus spreads sufficiently, it does mean the former. So to speak. (I've discussed those particular examples previously; the links are on the upper right). 

So three newish examples. The first fits the pattern to a T. I've heard it before, but here is a recent, public example from the teevee. Victoria MacDonald of Channel Four News used 'incredulous' for 'incredible' (or 'really incredible!'), saying 'It was really incredulous.'  But of course -- assuming the old meaning -- strictly speaking, that is ungrammatical nonsense:  You can say x finds the thing incredible, but not that x finds the thing incredulous. What does make sense is that x is incredulous at the thing. The incredible thing vs. the incredulous person (in linguistics, you can say the agent and patient roles are reversed).  The second doesn't fit the pattern, but fits it as it were in reverse.  Twice now I have heard 'invertebrate' being used where surely what was meant was 'inveterate'. Now all people know the word 'invertebrate', and very few really know the word 'inveterate'. My diagnosis is that the person is vaguely aware that there is such word, but can't quite recall it, and the only word they know that approximates it is 'invertebrate'. If anything 'inveterate' connotes unchanging rigidity where 'invertebrate' connotes lassitude, but there it is.

The third example is closer. A person is speaking about a man preparing a group for the main event, and intends something like 'prelude', or 'preface', or perhaps 'preliminary', but says 'He laid down a predicate for the event'. 

Tiny Things

Some minor malfunctions I've witnessed (some recently): 

one in the same for one and the same

I could care less for I couldn't care less (this has been around for a long time, I think)

intensive purposes for intents and purposes 

nip in the butt for nip in the bud (!) 

could of for could have (perhaps this too has been with us for long time)

deep seeded resentment for deep seated resentment (this is favourite of mine) 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Sunday, 16 June 2024

Generalisation, Holding Beliefs, Single Persons, and Winning


Another Dodge: The Particular to the General

This is another one which I'm surprised isn't recognized and called out by Nick Robinson and his R4 cohorts more often.  A presenter is interviewing some Tory bigwig, asking for a response to a EDL rally which descended into a fracas. 'Let me be clear: No violence should be tolerated', says the Tory. What's wrong with that? Who would deny it? The problem is that implicit in the initial line of questioning is that there is a particular problem with the EDL--that perhaps they should be disbanded or steps should taken against its leaders, or something, and one might think that the Tories in particular are likely to bear a certain responsibility. And of course many EDL members or sympathisers do vote Tory; the Tory is leery of offending them. The Tory responds to the question by generalising the issue, thereby diverting the questioner from a particular sore point. (It's a bit like 'What aboutism'.) In the cut-and-thrust atmosphere of a R4 interview, the necessary time and effort required to pursue that issue may be too great, as well the Tory knows. 

Holding Cognitive States

One has emotions. One has beliefs. But sometimes people speak of 'holding' emotions, of 'holding' beliefs. If find this a little strange. I can't help but think that implies that the action is more voluntary than it can possibly be, perhaps with a bit of irrationality mixed in. 'He holds the belief that she is faithful to him', as if the belief were like a dog whose leash one holds, or like a suspect one holds in a jail cell. What can be 'held' is perhaps a slogan, a form of words; one can decide stick to the words even if one has doubts. For emotions, is there an equivalent way of excuse? Maybe: maybe we can speak of a man as 'clinging' to his sadness, as 'holding on' to his sadness, when it is unhealthy to be sad for so long. We say: Snap out of it!  

Families

Keir Starmer, Rishi Sunak and others don't speak so much of ordinary people and their financial struggles (with inflation, taxes, etc.), preferring to speak of the plight of 'families'.  What of the many people who live alone? There are I believe nine million such people. Many of them, they would do well to reflect, not only pay taxes etc., but vote. 

Winning the t -- d 

We speak of 'winning the thread', when some commenter in social media or a chatroom makes an especially perceptive, and typically witty post, one that can't be topped. But all of a sudden, people now speak of 'winning the trend'. I can't help but think that this got started through mis-reading or mis-hearing the earlier 'winning the thread', and for some reason it caught on. If that's what happened, then the phenomenon is not so dire as what happened with 'refute' or 'disinterest', but still it is retrograde, for unlike the straightforward 'thread', it is a little hazy what 'trend' means here. 

Saturday, 29 July 2023

Calvin Talk

A Tory politician spoke of some bit of mild malfeasance as an occasion when 'Learnings' were to be had. This the reverse of Calvin's Verbing Nouns: it's a case of Nouning Verbs. A somewhat related case. a somewhat odd case, comes from of all people Richie Sunak, who spoke of his policy giving the green light to oil extraction as being 'pragmaticker' in comparison with the alternative. This is a case of making a preposition out of an adjective, or a relation out of a property. 

A Familiar Dodge

The tendency amongst the great & the powerful is very familiar -- but nonetheless maddening -- of reacting to having been caught in an act of serious impropriety with 'We got it wrong!', 'Mistakes were made! etc. The interviewee admits wrongdoing, but counts on the ambiguity created in the interviewer's mind -- an ambiguity between mere mistakes, like missing a three-inch putt in golf, and acts for the which criticism would be much graver, would be moral -- and hopes the conversation will move on. It almost always does. Is there a journalist who makes a habit of stopping the interviewee and asking if the wrongness were of ethics rather than mere skill? A fraudster who says 'I got it wrong!' is not genuinely admitting the nature of his crime. Perhaps Nick Robinson, Andrew Neil or James O'Brien calls this out.

A recent example from the US of A: 

Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas reported three 2022 trips on the private jet of a Texas billionaire in a financial disclosure form released Thursday, and for the first time detailed the businessman’s purchase of three properties from the justice’s family years earlier,” the Washington Post reports.

Thomas also acknowledged 'mistakes' in past reports, involving bank accounts, a life insurance policy and the name of his wife’s real estate company.

This is related to the famous 'Non-apology apology'.  Not 'I'm sorry', but 'If you took offense then I'm sorry'. or 'I'm sorry for any offense I caused'; often with the tacit or implied sub-text, 'But I didn't mean it'. One says 'sorry' only in the sense of being sorry at the situation in Afghanistan, not of acknowledging any personal responsibility. Indeed it is not an apology, but only a conditional apology, which in my book is not, not even where the condition is satisfied, an apology at all.  It often borders on 'victim blaming': [unspoken] 'If you looked upon my actions as racist/bullying/whatever, the fault lies with your perception, mate'. 

Over and Under

It is difficult to underplay the seriousness of the charges leveled at him. (Andrew Buncombe)

Ordinarily, to get mixed up when employing such forms of speech is eminently forgivable, but not when you're a journalist, for Pete's sake!  

This sort of thing is not far from saying 'I could care less', 'could of', or 'intensive purposes'. 





 





Wednesday, 15 February 2023

May and May Not. 

This has been around for a long time, or rather has been bothering me for a long time (I'm sensitive). When the speaker is a tiny bit nervous perhaps, they'll say something like: "The client may or may not choose the expensive option".  There is no reason to say "or may not". To say "The client may choose the expensive option" obviously (conversationally) implies that the client is not being forced to choose the expensive option.  In the example that I'm thinking of, she is at least subliminally aware of this; there was a little micro-pause between the first 'may' and the phrase 'or may not'; i.e.:  "The client may ... or may not .. choose the expensive option".  

Going Forward in Future

Two related things that have me scratching me head. 

(1) One is the use of 'going forward' to announce that the phrase about to be stated is to be understood as pertaining to the future.  But this is the job of the future tense! Which such people in such cases do use; they're not so grammatically benighted as to lose their sense of tense. It's another case of mere verbal clutter. If they dispensed with 'going forward', their message would no less clear. 

(2) In Britain it's common to speak of 'in future' rather than 'in the future'.  It seems not to be associated with class, age, or region. You hear it all over the place (north, south, east and west).  It isn't obligatory in British English; one hears plenty of 'in the future's.  But why 'in future'?  No one speaks of 'in past'. 


Monday, 23 May 2022

Politicians Speak 97


Four linguistic tricks/maneuvers that are popular amongst politicians, some of which you're no doubt familiar with. 

1. 'We injected a record x pounds ...'.  I'm surprised they aren't called out on this more often. It is rather easy to make such claims, as the population is always increasing and inflation is always happening (except in unusual circumstances).  So naturally this will in general be true, be it funds for water, for the railroads, for disabled kids, etc., even if the real spending per head inches down.   

2. Another one that seems to slip by unremarked, thus securing its effectiveness.  'We got that wrong'. said Dominic Raab on Partygate (the Morning Show, BBC 20/05/2022.) Compare this with 'We did something wrong'. The former implies no moral blame; it could just as well be said of an incorrect answer on The News Quiz, or a football substitution that didn't pan out. The latter suggests otherwise, suggests moral blameworthiness. But they are very similar, and Raab can reasonably hope that suspension between the two will occupy the listeners mind for just long enough for the conversation to move on. 

3. 'I'm not going to get into hypotheticals'.  Of course ... you know.  Maddening. Why don't journalists call them out more often? 'So you're not getting into "hypotheticals" ... so you would refuse to answer: "If the Queen were assaulted with a knife, would you intervene?"'.  'Ah, so you would answer? So it's not the case that you refuse to answer conditionals. So again I ask you ... ?'. Indeed the logician in me wants to say: 'Are all monkeys mammals? Yes? So you would agree that if something is a monkey, it is a mammal, right? So have we not got into hypotheticals, as you put it?'.

4.  'That's why we're ... '.  This is very common. A representative of the government is interviewed (Sunak, Rabb, Truss etc.).  It is put to them that such-and-such is a big problem, voters are worried, and why haven't you ... To which the answer is 'That's why we're (whatever action or money spent can plausibly be portrayed as directed to the problem; and there always is). That is, the government is already on top of it; it's got your back. They are mildly irritated that you should suppose otherwise. 'That's why ... why don't you journalists see?'. 

Wednesday, 4 May 2022

1. Nonsense vs. a nonsense. 

'Nonsense', in the first instance, pertains to the meaning of a phrase or a sentence; either it has sense (it makes sense), or it's nonsense (it makes no sense).  Either it is semantically, lexicographically and grammatically in order, or something is semantically, lexicographically or grammatically very wrong; it fails to express a coherent thought. 

'Nonsense' is an adjective, but one occasionally finds the use of the term as a noun, ie 'a nonsense' (I've come across this use even by Frank Ramsey!). 'A nonsense' implies that one can count nonsenses, which one might well resist.  Is it connected with the senses? I see an image of a blind man groping - that he can't find his way; that to say 'It's a nonsense' is roughly to say 'I see nothing with it', or 'One cannot use it to see anything'.  

There is also a use where what has been said succeeds in expressing a thought, but where the thought is egregiously false. Perhaps this use is connected with the first, in that if we have an example of nonsense (of this second variety), then no coherent case can be made for it. 

2. Paradoxes of Relativism. 

The central paradox being that it is self-defeating to proclaim that all is relative. Is it relative to say that all is relative? If it is not, then not all is relative; but if one proclaims that it is, one adopts a point of view from which it is not (there is one thing that one can say that is not relative, namely that all is relative). It is not actually a paradox, but it seems necessarily false.     

Frequently the 'paradox' is met with in lower grades, ones that are not in themselves self-contradictory.  Once in while it emerges with special poignancy. Boris Johnson recently announced a relaxation of the Covid-era rule that social isolation is mandatory if you have a positive test: It will no longer be enforced.

An interviewer:

What do you think of Boris's announcement? 

Interviewee: 

Well, for me, I'd say you should isolate. 

Does he mean 'I should isolate'? No. Something stronger.  Does he mean 'Everyone should isolate'? He would say he didn't mean that, either. The interviewee is struggling.

What is going on? Maybe people do believe that matters of morality are not, at all events, relative, but that it's uncool to say it.  It's uncool to play the preacher-man; one doesn't like the responsibility that the institution of morality demands. 

I connect the phenomenon with the newish habit, in writing, of ending certain declarative sentences with a question mark. People are hesitant to make assertions, to use outright declarative sentences, on certain topics. 

3.  'It's incredulous!' 

Though not often but I venture increasingly, the word is sometimes used for incredible, for a phenomenon (not a person, as is required by 'incredulous'). I've also heard of 'contemptuous' being said for 'contemptible'.  An example from an advertisement for a kitchen utensil: 

The Original Milk Frother has a $17 price tag, which isn’t bad at all considering it makes the most delicious foam and is far from Starbs’ incredulous prices for a simple cup of joe.

This is an attempt to compensate for being lexicographically shaky by making up new uses of words, that, though only to their fellow linguistic deficients at most, will seem learned, rather than as further confirmation of their deficiency. 

4. [Cancelled! I was WRONG! I'll leave up as penance]

 'Defenestration'

The word means removal of windows, especially if the removal is violent (notorious with the Protestant thugs of the 16th century). Dylan Byers obtained a recording of a CNN staff meeting with WarnerMedia CEO Jason Kilar, to explain the network’s sudden dismissal of Jeff Zucker:

It did not go well. The meeting, which I obtained a recording of last night, highlights the profound sense of loyalty that CNN’s on-air talent have toward their longtime leader, despite his violation of company policy, and the anger they feel regarding the circumstances of his sudden defenestration.

No comment. 

 



Thursday, 30 December 2021

3 Minor Matters

1: So

A familiar part of English speech is the locution ' .. so .. that ...', as illustrated by

He was driving so fast that he had no chance to make that corner.

Or: 

She was so good at chess that no one wanted to play her.

The construct is something like: [Noun phrase] [be] so [adjectival phrase][relative clause].  This use of 'so' has it as a somewhat complicated adverb, intensifying the following adjective but also requiring a clause following the adjective ('that no one wanted to play her'). 

But now the word 'so' is often used simply as an adverb in its own right, like 'very'.  'She was so good!', etc.  It's like a comparative that has lost its object. [JL points out that this is actually very old; nevertheless I think that its popularity has increased manifold]. 

I have often indulged in it.  I feel its power.  But I fear its effectiveness will be temporary. The effect it now has depends on listeners being aware of the comparative, that they will join me in half expecting it but being indulgent if it does not in fact come. They don't really care what in particular should take the place of the comparative clause marked by 'that', as it is intimated that some comparative could be articulated, and that is enough.  Like an ellipsis.  But that awareness, that expectation, will go.  It'll just be like 'very'. 

2: Really 

(Yorkshire, Lancashire, ...?). When you've said that p—'The defendant was guilty'— but somehow not with the emphasis or panache you'd have liked, you can tack on 'really'.  As in 'p, really'.  'The defendant was guilty, really'.  Now if I'm not mistaken (a pretty big 'if', I grant), this is not just a vacuous phrase, but serves to express the speaker's being not quite at ease in speaking as they have just done.  The word literally says 'Yes, that is the right word!', but what the speaker conveys is a certain dissatisfaction, as if the speaker did not quite succeed in expressing the meaning satisfactorily. It may be compared with '... you know what I mean?'.  Or, it is as if one's turn to speak has ended too soon. I thought there was something more! ('Is that all there is? ... If that's all there is my friend..then lets keep dancing; let's break out the booze, and have a ball').

3: Rising Intonation

This is not strictly a matter of lexicography and not even strictly of grammar, but it is so distinctive and has appeared so suddenly that it's worth commenting on (to use 'so' in the old way). I reckon it's been with us for about twenty years or so in the speech of the young but it has become rampant in the general population for only about five years (correct me if I'm wrong). This is the practice of using a rising intonation—typically reserved for questions asked with the declarative form, as in 'You want the menu?'—for a genuine statement, an assertion, where the signal conveyed is normally (though not always) that the speaker is not done speaking; what follows is another declarative statement, or another declarative conjunct or disjunct preceded by 'and' or 'or'. Typically but not always again, the speaker will do this at the beginning of their turn, with the rest of their statements or clauses following the old conventional downward-tending pattern. 

In writing it happens too, that a statement is made using the normal declarative, but a question-mark is added all the same. I assume as before that the speech-act remains that of making a statement, even if the assertoric force conveyed is thereby dialed back. Unlike examples discussed in the previous paragraph, it occurs typically not at the beginning of the piece of writing, but near the end. Often it will have the modal adverb 'maybe' (or equivalent) governing the main verb.  For example the closing sentence of a comment in a thread might be, 'Maybe we ought to relax?'.  I take it that that speech-act would be of the same category if the question mark were removed. 

Another sort of example in writing:

He passed his hand over his forehead, a little wild-looking, as if he himself had suffered only a narrow escape. "I think about it every single day. I still see her face, you know, getting into that cab? Waving goodbye, so happy." (Donna Tartt, The Goldfinch, p. 215)

Of course Tartt was not writing an academic paper or a piece of journalism.  It's a case of the author trying to be realistic in her reported speech, accurate to her imaginary protagonists—who in this case are young people in the US I think around 2010 (the speaker is Goldie, a Latino working at a parking garage).    

Why has this phenomenon come about? As far as I can see, it serves two purposes.  

The first, as in the example from Donna Tartt, is the benign one that it serves as a sort of conversational check-in: I imagine the speaker simultaneously looking up at into his listener's eyes, looking for recognition at an especially fraught or emotional moment of his speech. 'You with me?', or 'You feel me?'. It encourages intimacy, connection. 

The second is somewhat more disturbing.  Again the signal is to check in, but not normally with a look that beseeches intimacy.  It signals a rather lack of confidence in what one is saying, either lexically or factually. It is not accidental that the tone is normally reserved for one of questioning. I can't help but take this development as a sign that it holds of mankind in general, or at any rate of a certain culture of English-speakers: it signals, across the age, a loss of confidence, of certainty. It's almost as if the very practice of assertion is slowly being chipped away in a minor Orwellian nightmare: Here are some words; I am not asserting them, I'm not saying they're true, I just raise them for consideration, ok? They came to mind. I'll take them back if you don't like them. 

I would say that we have here the birth of a new variety of speech-act, of force, but we already have such devices as 'Perhaps ...', or 'I suggest that ...', and so on. 

Tuesday, 21 December 2021

The Death of Swearing, and the Concept Concept

Not very long ago, cursing or swearing was considered a taboo of speech.  It was considered bad manners or worse.  'Fuck', 'shit' and so on were not heard on television or radio, would never be uttered in the hearing of your children, your parents, your grandparents, in the office, in public speeches, and so on.  They were reserved for shows of genuine unhinged frustration or anger, for groups of eighteen year-olds on the prowl, and so on.  But it has changed rather quickly. Now almost everywhere these words are much more likely to be let fall, to the point where their being bleeped-out on the BBC seems artificial, as protecting no one. 

My habits have not been affected, and indeed for whatever reason I almost never swear.  I bring this up because the change seems to remove swearing from its presumably rightful place in one's psychological economy.  Certain words had the effect, when uttered in the heat of the moment, of blowing off steam, precisely because, I assume, they were forbidden.  In such circumstances—say if I've hit my thumb when hammering a nail—the words do pour out. Now there are no words left with anything like that sort of pungency. There is still a little of it—one wouldn't swear in the hearing of the Queen I suppose—but we seem to be approaching a world bereft of proper swearing because the words which once had the status of swear-words no longer quite have it, and it seems impossible that new ones will take their place.  Will we suffer from no longer having the release of swearing? 

The Concept Concept.

Are concepts the meanings of words? I have always thought so—unthinkingly as a native English speaker, and then thinkingly, as a philosopher.  Not that there is anything theoretically deep going on; 'concept' is no more penetrating than the ordinary notion of the meaning of a word. One speaks of concepts rather than word-meanings primarily to transcend any reference to a particular language: the concept equality is thought to be meant by the English word 'equality', the French word 'égalité', and the Spanish word 'igualdad'.  Equipped with this word, we can speculate about early Homo Sapiens; we can ask whether they had the concept equality, freely granting of course they didn't have the English word 'equality' although with the vague assumption that he had some language or other. Indeed we could speak of the notion rather than the concept (I've always liked that word—it doesn't pretend to be more precise than it is). Anyway we could have these conversations without using the word 'concept'. If awkwardly, one can speak of the meaning of the word 'equality', meaning a certain entity to which the word bears a certain semantic relation, and of Jack, Pierre, and Juan's mental grasp of this entity, without implying that there is a language common to any two of the listed speakers. 

But some people think that speaking of concepts gets us closer to the real facts; indeed some think they are the stuff of what Fodor called the Language of Thought. Superficially, it has always struck me that that is at most an unnatural position, for it appears to imply that there are concepts corresponding to most if not all words—not only the concept duck, the concept rock, but the concept every, the concept in, the concept put, and so on (I think of an adaptation of a point by Wittgenstein: What concept is expressed by the finger?).  I suppose I know what it means to speak that way, but such is not the language of the street, and seems to amount to what we've learned from Moliere to call a dormative virtue explanation, a trumped-up vacuous explanation. For example from YouTube videos, it is clear that for example a crow can figure out how to use a stick to retrieve a treat from some complicated setup, but does this suggest that the crow grasps concepts? What is to be gained? 


Saturday, 18 December 2021

More Tics: Two Modern Intensifiers

'I've always been clear'

More than the average person, politicians are averse to coming off as uncertain or vague, as having only a tenuous grasp of the issues.  To combat this, the best antidote is to speak well, engagingly, and to the point—not to disappoint the audience with automatic, wooden and tired cliches.  But the latter is the effect— not merely on me I'm fairly certain—of the habit, widespread among politicians, of beginning seemingly every statement of their position on an important topic with "I've always been clear that ..''.  Sadiq Khan, for example, addressing the problem of rape and sexual harassment in London:

I've always been clear that violence against women and girls is unacceptable. (Facebook, March 21 2019). 

Indeed the effect is to sow a seed of doubt about whether what follows is a position sincerely held, as opposed to its just being politically expedient or necessary to be seen as having held (as if one could ever be less than clear about the acceptability of such violence).  True, sometimes one does need some such device, for setting off a statement, for making clear that what immediately follows is especially important, or serves as a general summing-up of the argument the details of which one is about to provide.  But the effect on the listener of this sort of repetition—of 'I've always been clear that'—is not that.  Either it is to announce, if subliminally, in a boiler-plate way as taught by media coaches, that what is to follow is not original, probably indeed a mere dreary statement of the party-line; or—more likely in Khan's case—that what is to follow is a statement on a difficult and dangerous issue, so difficult and dangerous that he must rely on a pre-conceived speech as advised by one's handlers rather than improvising in the normal manner.  The words have so to speak the form of what linguists call an 'intensifier', but have in fact a deflationary effect, of signaling that the speaker is not wholly present, is not quite speaking from the heart. 

An intensifier that is grammatically the same but has a certain ethical dimension is 'It's right that ...', viz. Theresa May:

It is right that Priti Patel​ has resigned over secret meetings in Israel (quoted in The Guardian, Nov. 8 2017).

I hear this device as expressing something ethical, so the device is not wholly vacuous like prefacing an assertion with 'It is the case that'.   Indeed in comparison with the above use of 'I've been clear ...', this device, ahem, is acceptably clear. Nevertheless I don't approve. It is first of all inflexible, wooden and unimaginative (like that mildly irritating habit of certain analytic philosophers of always expressing negation as 'It is not the case that ...').  Of all the multitudinous ways in which one might express in English one's approbation, that this should be chosen, is most disappointing. Second, there is again in this form of words a whiff of discharging of one's responsibility, of not wanting to play the prelate, as if one were reporting the outcome of some disinterested inquiry whose job is to determine moral or political standing—as in 'The white paper concluded that Priti Patel was correct to resign'.  (A nice question is whether the matter is a moral rather than political one). If I'm right about that, then changing it to 'I think it right that ...' changes the speech-act.  

A case could made that both of these phenomena should be chalked up primarily to a certain laziness of grammar.   In English we have an easy, all-purpose but tiresome way of linking one thing to another by saying 'in terms of', as in 'In terms of her drinking I was ok with it' (rather than simply 'I was ok with her drinking'); or 'Replacing the windows is difficult to justify in terms of cost' (rather than 'It is difficult to justify the cost of replacing the windows').  Or we allude to the importance of something without having to say how or why it is important, or even whether 'important' is quite the word one wants, by simply saying 'It's about x'.  For example one might stress the importance of rhythm in jazz by saying 'It's about rhythm'.  At least grammatically, 'I've been clear that ...' and 'It's right that ...' perform a similar function, in that they are always the same—placed at the beginning a sentence or clause and have no further grammatical implications—and saves one the trouble of expressing more detailed, nuanced or subtle ideas, ones that require a firmer grammatical sense.  

The effect of these is to make speech more boring.   

Saturday, 4 December 2021

Going Forward, On what it means to be ill

The recent ubiquity of the phrase going forward is difficult to explain. Examples: 

Will online soap operas become more the norm going forward?
If the government changes into one less respectful of human rights then we need to know what safeguards there will be going forward.

We can erase the final two words of such sentences without loss. That is why we have the future tense. What is strange is that there is no confusion displayed by the use of 'going forward', and it is not pretentious; no one feels puffed up, clever or cool by sticking it in.  Only a false sense of command, perhaps. 

The closest like phenomenon is the use of 'actual' or 'actually'.  It does some semantic work, contrasting a modal, hypothetical, or thought-to-be case with the actual case, as in:

Such an assailant would have had to be a fast runner; we know the actual assailant had only one leg.

It serves to signal that the scope of 'would' does not include the term that follows. There is also the case where it does not have, strictly speaking, a semantic function, but it has an analogous and quite excusable pragmatic function:

This equation holds where the bodies involved are situated on a friction-less plane. Of course, there are actually no such planes. 

But bombs are unbelievable until they actually fall.

She looks young, but she's actually 50.

It's not clear who actually pulled the trigger.

Strictly you could say the same thing by erasing 'actually', but it does serve as a useful indicator to the listener, that after musing on or being misled by other scenarios, the real case is thus and so.  It's related to prefacing what you say with 'Basically, ... ', 'Now, ...', or 'Listen, ...'. 

But one can easily get what Nick Zangwill once called the 'actually' bug, putting it in to one's sentences too liberally, to the point of its being an irritating nervous tic. As in: 

When the ball actually came to me, it was so easy to actually put it past the keeper. 

Or a headline in the Sun:

A Young Woman Refugee On What it’s Actually Like to Cross the Channel!

So is 'going forward' like this degenerate use of 'actually'?  It's tempting to think so.  But it is not, as is the case with 'actually', a case of peeling away from an established and valuable use. I've no solution. 

What it means to be ill

To be ill, to an one speaking U.S. English, is to have an infection, or more generally to have some disease.  Unlike the U.S. use, the British use of 'ill' also includes, for example, having a broken leg.  It covers almost any incapacity.

But not any.  If your arm is chopped off, you don't become ill-for-life.  If you're born with a disability, you're not thereby ill.  Yet it does not mean having something temporary either; if one contracts a incurable form of cancer one is still ill (even if the cancer merely dwells within you but makes no significant difference to your life or life-span).  

It seems to me that the U.S.-use is clearer. 



Thursday, 14 October 2021

Instances, Incidents, Incidences

This phenomenon has slowly snowballed over many years.  It doesn't involve any notable conceptual confusion other than the milder ignorance of the relevant words, but it has further dimensions which I'll get to.  People will say, in place of (the correct) 'past instances' of some kind of event, 'past incidences' of the kind of event. 

A doctor is conferring with the family of a stroke victim under fifty:
He's a young man. He shouldn't be having such incidences! (Dark Water, Netflix)
I've heard people anxiously garble the somewhat difficult to enunciate 'in-ci-den-ces', or even to begin saying 'instances' only to 'correct' themselves with 'incidences'.  Aside from the impropriety of usage, why think the more tortuous word is the one to use, when the easier one would do, which everyone understands?  No doubt people know the term 'incidents', which denote a certain sub-class of instances.  Is this mistaken use of 'incidences' a mere mispronunciation of 'incidents', or a graver sort of mistake?  To speak properly of the incidence of a kind of event is not to speak of a particular case of the event, but to speak of its frequency, the rate at which it happens.  

It could be because I'm getting examples mostly via Radio 4, but it may have to do with the fact that it often happens when a person is trying to sound more intellectual or more official, if not more officious, than is their wont; perhaps they have some dim association of incidences with graphs, even with inflection points.  

Again, the case follows the usual pattern:  An ordinary word - 'instance' - is phonetically close to a more exotic word that is it least in the same semantic ballpark - 'incidence'.  Some person, unaware of the difference in meaning, uses the second for the first, and for some inscrutable reason, the virus proves to be catching.  

Thursday, 2 September 2021

They Sadly Died

They Sadly Died

Of late, whenever a newscaster announces deaths--a car crash, coronavirus, terrorist bomb etc.--they say that people sadly died. You might think this is a courteous show of feeling, but of course since 'sadly' has become de rigueur, it is nothing of the sort; it is only a cluttering of speech.  The devil in me wants to ask, after the newscaster says thus-and-so many people sadly died of coronavirus, how many additional victims went out defiantly, angrily, or even jubilantly?  Another devil in me wants to know, exactly whose sadness are you speaking of?  The dead person's?   The deceased person's friends and family? Seems presumptuous. Your own?  Or is it impersonal, as in the 'sad fact of their dying'?  

Written journalism has also caught the bug.  Today I read: 

When officers arrived they found two infants inside the vehicle, and they were sadly pronounced dead at the scene by emergency paramedics. 


 

Thursday, 27 May 2021

Entitlement

Entitlement

One used to say such things as 'She has a sense of entitlement'; 'She thinks that she is entitled to walk in without an appointment'; 'Yes, she is entitled to be paid that sum'; 'All members of the club are entitled to two drinks at the bar'. It is always entitlement-for, a transitive expression:  In the first example, the object is tacit, but it is understood that the subject believes she entitled to something or other, normally if not inevitably something desirable.  And, most important for the point I'm about to make, entitlement is something granted by others--by social or legal contract, or by those unspoken agreements that exist between us. 

But now people say 'She's entitled!', an apparently intransitive phenomenon, a one-place predicate, meaning a property, not a relation (for a whole book about it, see Entitled: How Male Privilege Hurts Women, by Kate Manne). What they mean, on the older way of speaking, is 'She has a sense of entitlement', or 'She assumes she is entitled (to something)'.  In fact it is possible to be entitled in the new sense without actually being entitled the old sense.  To say one is entitled in the new sense is primarily a remark about one's own state of mind.  Entitlement in the old sense, by contrast, was an achievement, a 'title' one had to earn, or be granted as a matter of one's social or legal standing.  Not only is one's state of mind not sufficient for entitlement in the old sense, no particular state of mind is necessary: one can perfectly well be entitled to something, in the old sense, without being aware of it, or indeed while believing that one is not entitled to it.  Now, contrariwise, to say 'She's entitled' is more often than not taken to mean, precisely, that she lacks the standing she thinks she has, that, in the old sense of the word, she is not entitled.  

Is any confusion generated by the potential ambiguity between the two senses?  I said above that, unlike the old sense, to say one is entitled in the new sense is primarily a remark about one's own state of mind.  Is it merely such a remark?  A bit of field work perhaps is necessary; ask subjects whether it is possible for one to be mistaken in thinking one is entitled.  I suspect results would not be uniform, a sign that echoes of the old sense are still present. 

Wednesday, 28 April 2021

Redundancy of 'Mights'

Redundancy of 'Mights'

Today a person in government said (of Boris J) that they're "going to conduct an inquiry to find out whether there is any evidence that malfeasance might have been committed". No, this makes me cringe a little.  That is like saying "It's possible that it's possible".  Deniers of S4 aside (and setting aside Two-Dimensionalism), that is just an overly wordy way, that is a redundant way, of saying "It's possible," or, in today's case, that they're "going to conduct an inquiry to find out whether there is any evidence that malfeasance was committed" (or - thanks DL - that they're "going to conduct an inquiry to find out whether there is any evidence of  malfeasance").  That there is evidence that something happened does not prove, of course, that the thing happened. It is just evidence. 

Why do people speak this way?  Possibly it's just a shaky grasp of grammar; one can well-imagine the speaker, her or his eyes going vacant when speaking the sentence.  But it might also be a certain humility; one can imagine the inner dialogue: "This thing is possible; that's all I want to say and don't want anyone thinking I'm saying more than that.  Better put in 'might' or 'possible' wherever I can, just to make sure".  Or maybe both are at work. 

Sunday, 28 March 2021

Qualitative and Quantitative

Qualitative and Quantitative

In 1971 the UK changed its coinage system, from a system where twelve pennies make a shilling, and twenty shillings make a pound (I know very little about it, but they tell me also of tanners - not tenners - ha'pennies, half-crowns, farthings, thrupenny bit, and more), to a more sensible decimal system, like the US system, which has always been decimal (and of course the Euro).  Just as one hundred cents make a dollar, one hundred pence make a pound, and the shilling was retired. 

The people were not invariably pleased, I hear.  Among other things, this has always struck me as symptomatic of a more general phenomenon of people disliking brute numbers as a means of thinking, especially when evaluating things.  One prefers to have a remnant of barter, where your units were a pound of apples, a healthy cow at 2 years age, and so on.  As if you don't really know how much you're getting until translated into things of real value--apples, cows, or indeed, somewhat ironically, gold or silver (and this is in a sense true).  Not only does it seem colder to speak of 100 units rather than twelve or twenty etc., it's as if a pound just happened to be equivalent to twenty schillings, but it is not equal to twenty schillings, it's not the same thing; maybe tomorrow it will be worth twenty-one!

The same thing happened with the shift from the Imperial system of weights and measures--stones, pounds, inches, feet, miles--to the more orderly Metric System; fourteen pounds make a stone; twelve inches make a foot, 5280 feet make a mile, and things get very complicated when speaking of ounces, pints, quarts, gallons, etc., a complexity which is exacerbated with differences between US vs UK systems.  Although for some purposes (such as the distances on road signs), people still use the old system (in any event I don't see that there is anything psychological going on here).

In music, the British speak of semibreves, minims, crotchets, quavers, and semi-quavers.  In the US, it's a more rational, and easier to learn and memorize 'decimal' system, with whole notes, half-notes, quarter-notes, and eighth-notes (and sixteenth-notes and so on).  Again, it's as if the crotchet has an intrinsic quality that is not to be compared with that of the quaver.    

This is somehow similar to weather forecasting terminology in Britain as opposed to the US.  In the US, the forecasts convey the predictions in a scientific style; they'll speak dryly of  'an 80% chance of precipitation', 'humidity over 90%', 'Low temperature overnight of 40 degrees' (although in the relatively folksy degrees Fahrenheit).  In the UK it is more subjective and homespun in style: they'll say 'It's going to be wet out there! Galoshes all round! Rain, or even snow very likely!'; the 'Beast from the East!'; 'It will feel cold; a chilling wind lies in store for us!'; 'The sun is trying come out but I don't think it'll succeed!'; 'Bit and bobs of mist are still hanging round!' 'We're in for a stiff dose of the wet stuff!'. 'And that's your weather, Helen!'. (I could go on). 

I also hear some echo of the difference, with respect to the qualitative-quantitative distinction, in the sale of medicines.  In the US, names (and the character of the packaging) encourage you to think that you're trusting science, the latest hi-tech; in the UK, to think of your auntie, your tried and trusted home remedies.  'Corocidin', 'Nyquil' , 'Mucinex' vs 'Lemsip', 'Night Nurse' or 'Beecham's'.  The difference is however lessening, I believe.

Hypotheses?  I don't think it's that the people in the UK more likely to cling to primitive ways of thinking, or let alone that they're not mathematically as advanced as the Yanks. The 1950's and especially the 1960's made science -- the realm of mathematics -- very much the thing in the US.  Americans got very puffed up about the atom bomb, B-52s and Doomsday, lasers, scanners, sonar, radar, going to the the Moon, transistors, computers.  All, at least one was led to believe, American inventions.  It was partly genuine American pride which survived from the end of Second World War until it began to fizzle out in say the 1980's, that perhaps explains the points about Medicines and the Weather.  And the other points can perhaps be explained independently, perhaps just as accidents of history.  But maybe one needs to remark the forest here, not just the trees.  Taken together, maybe these do suggest a difference between the British and the American Character. 

Prosecute/Persecute; Invidious 

The difference between the verbs to prosecute and to persecute is showing signs of being lost.  A recent story about none other than Donald Trump, speaking of the riots in Washington DC, 6th of January 2021: 

Trump also complained that law enforcement was now “persecuting” the Capitol rioters, hundreds of whom have been arrested, while “nothing happens” to left-wing protesters.

I predict that the adjective 'invidious'--so very good in suitable spots, expressing a complicated meaning, of a distinction which will cause undue division -- will go the way of 'begging the question' or 'refute'.  It will come to mean, when said of a person such as Trump, 'too individual' or 'unduly selfish'.  Just you watch.   


Saturday, 3 October 2020

In Future, Exponential

 In Future, and Exponential

I've long thought that speaking of 'in future', rather than 'in the future', was a mark -- in Britain -- of not quite having had the best education (or not benefiting from it).  I mean goodness, no one speaks of 'in past', rather than 'in the past' (do they?).  But lo and behold, Robin Collingwood, in his Intellectual Autobiography, speaks in that way--'in future'.  Collingwood was no slouch. 

In another case of fine distinctions being lost -- this can be laid at the door of the Coronavirus pandemic, I mean if correlation is causation (:  -- 'exponential', which has traditionally had its precise mathematical meaning, is, if recent speech is a sign, in danger of meaning 'rapid and scary!'.